Skip to content

The Practical Wallet

Home/How Your Credit Score Affects Car Insurance Rates

How Your Credit Score Affects Car Insurance Rates

Advertisement

How Your Credit Score Affects Car Insurance Rates

Last updated: May 15, 2024
Key Takeaway:

Your credit score is often just as important as your driving record when companies set your car insurance rates. Improving your score can help you get a much cheaper rate.

How Your Credit Score Affects Car Insurance Rates

Quick Facts

  • Who: Drivers in most US states.
  • What: Insurance companies use credit-based insurance scores to set rates.
  • When: Every time you sign up for a new policy or renew.
  • Where: Allowed in 46 states, but banned in California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, and Michigan.
  • Why it matters: Drivers with poor credit can pay more than double the rate of drivers with excellent credit.

Your credit score can change how much you pay for car insurance. Most people think only their driving record matters. But in many states, credit history has a huge impact on your monthly bill.

Why Insurance Companies Care About Your Credit

Insurance companies want to know how likely you are to make a claim. Studies show that people with lower credit scores file more claims. Because of this, companies view low credit as a risk.

They use your credit history to create a special score. This is not the exact same score lenders use for credit cards. They look at your payment history and how much debt you owe.

Credit Scores vs Insurance Scores

Your regular credit score tells banks if you will pay back a loan. Your credit-based insurance score tells insurance companies how risky you are. Both scores look at the same data.

If you pay bills on time, both scores will go up. Late payments make both scores drop. Keeping track of bills is a great way to protect your wallet. You can find more tips on managing your money on Practical Walletz to stay on track.

How Much More Do You Pay with Poor Credit?

The price difference between good and bad credit can surprise you. A driver with poor credit might pay thousands of dollars more each year than a driver with excellent credit. Even if you have a perfect driving record, bad credit will still drive up your cost.

Let's look at the average yearly costs for drivers with different credit levels. These numbers show how much a low score can hurt your budget.

Credit Tier Average Yearly Rate Extra Cost Percentage
Excellent Credit $1,400 0% (Base Rate)
Good Credit $1,650 18% More
Fair Credit $2,100 50% More
Poor Credit $2,950 110% More

States That Ban Credit Checks for Car Insurance

Not every driver has to worry about this issue. A few states made it illegal for insurance companies to look at your credit. In these states, your rate depends on your driving record.

Here are the states that do not allow credit checks for car insurance:

  • California
  • Hawaii
  • Massachusetts
  • Michigan

In these states, companies focus on your years of driving experience. They also look at past accidents or tickets.

How to Lower Your Insurance Bill with Low Credit

If your state allows credit checks, do not lose hope. You can still find ways to make your insurance affordable. Shop around and get quotes from different companies. Some do not weigh credit scores heavily.

You can also check our guide on saving money to see other smart ways to lower your bills. Paying off small debts will raise your score quickly. Be sure to check your credit report for errors.

Other Factors That Keep Your Rates High

Your credit is not the only thing that sets your rate. Insurance companies look at many details to decide your price.

These details include your car type and how many miles you drive. Your age and location also play a part. A clean driving record can help offset a lower credit score.

How Often Do Insurance Companies Check Your Credit?

Most companies check your credit when you first apply. They might not check it again at renewal unless you ask.

If your credit score went up, ask your agent to rerun your score. This simple request could save you money. If your score went down, let the old score stay on file.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does shopping for car insurance hurt my credit score?

No, checking your rate does not hurt. Insurance companies use a soft pull, which does not affect your credit history.

Can I get car insurance if I have no credit history?

Yes, you can still get covered. But the insurance company may charge more because they lack proof of your payment habits.

How fast can an improved credit score lower my insurance?

It can happen when your policy renews. You just need to ask your company to check your new score.

What is a credit-based insurance score?

It is a rating that predicts how likely you are to file a claim. It uses credit report data to make this guess.

Do all insurance companies check credit?

Almost all companies check credit where it is legal. Specialty insurers that skip this step often charge higher rates anyway.

Keep an Eye on Your Credit to Save Money

Improving your credit is a great way to help your entire financial life. You will qualify for better credit cards, cheaper loans, and lower car insurance rates. Take small steps today, like setting up auto-pay, to start building a better score.

Sources:

National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) report on credit-based insurance scores. Consumer Reports study on car insurance rates and credit tiers.

Labels: , , , , ,